In partnership with

You Already Have a Take on What AI Does Next

OpenAI or Anthropic? Which model leads the next benchmark? Which company ships the next major breakthrough?

If you follow AI closely, you already have opinions on where the industry is headed. Kalshi lets you trade on real-world AI and technology events, with markets that move as models launch, benchmarks drop, and announcements happen.

The people who follow this space most closely often see the story developing before everyone else. Put that knowledge to work and trade what you think happens next.

Bonus credit varies from $15 to $500. Terms apply.

Latest posts

If you’re new, not yet a subscriber, or just plain missed it, here are some of our recent editions.

Partners

Interested in sponsoring these emails? See our partnership options here.

informed.now is the #1 news-by-SMS service in America. Replace toxic legacy news with a concise daily SMS of facts you can trust – free of ads, bias, and sensationalism. Be informed without being influenced. Get www.informed.now

Subscribe to the Life Self Mastery podcast, which guides you on getting funding and allowing your business to grow rocketship. 

Previous guests include Guy Kawasaki, Brad Feld, James Clear, Nick Huber, Shu Nyatta and 350+ incredible guests.

S1 Deep Dive

Cumberland Farms in one minute

Cumberland Farms files to go public on the Nasdaq under CMBY. Roughly $1 billion raised at a $9 billion valuation. Revenue of $16.3 billion, down 4%, and down three years running. Gross profit of $2.7 billion, flat since 2023. Adjusted EBITDA of $693 million, down 5%. A net loss of $145 million.

It is not a New England convenience chain. It is a European fuel business wearing a Massachusetts name it bought in 2019 and legally adopted 19 days before filing. Europe out-earned America last year, $364 million to $360 million, while US same-store gallons fell 1.2%.

The fine print: $5.8 billion of debt at 8x EBITDA, and $668 million of interest against $208 million of operating income. Interest ran 322% of operating income. They disclosed material weaknesses across all five COSO components. The ask is 21x EBITDA. ARKO, the closest comp, trades at 11.5x and is worth under a billion.

Introduction

A company changed its name to Cumberland Farms on June 23, then filed for a $9 billion IPO 19 days later.

Cumberland Farms is a 1939 New England dairy chain. The company doing the filing is a British petrol station operator that started with one forecourt in Bury, England in 2001, borrowed its way across three continents, and sold off half of itself to stay alive.

The name is the most American thing about this deal.

Here is what it actually is. Revenue of $16.3 billion, but most of that is wholesale gasoline passing through the register on its way back to the refiner. Start at gross profit instead. $2.7 billion, and it has not grown since 2023. Adjusted EBITDA of $693 million, falling. Debt of $5.8 billion. That is 8x.

Most companies go public around 2x or 3x. Eight is where private equity is still fixing the thing, not selling it.

Then the line that stopped me. Interest payments were 322% of income from operations. The stores made $208 million last year. The lenders took $668 million.

The plan to close that gap is fried chicken in 500 stores and new signage on 700 more.

History

Two brothers bought one petrol station in Bury, England in 2001.

Mohsin and Zuber Issa never stopped buying. In 2016, TDR Capital, a London private equity firm with €16 billion under management, merged its own forecourt business with theirs. That became EG Group.

Then they went shopping on borrowed money.

About 760 convenience sites from Kroger. 570 Cumberland Farms stores in 2019. 540 Woolworths sites in Australia. More than 2,000 Esso sites across Italy and Germany.

By the end of it they owned 3,242 stores across two continents and $5.8 billion of debt.

Since 2023 they have been selling it back. The UK for more than $3 billion. Italy for $450 million. Australia for $830 million. France is in escrow now.

In May 2023 they sold 414 US properties in a sale-leaseback for $1.5 billion and booked a $920 million gain. That gain is the entire reason 2023 shows $1.9 billion of net income. The cash went to lenders.

Buy the world on debt. Sell half the world to pay the interest.

What is left is America, Germany and Benelux, a Cayman charter, and a name they adopted last month.

Risk factors

One building in Westborough, Massachusetts supplies a significant portion of the merchandise in every American store.

It is 431,000 square feet. It is also the only place the company stamps cigarette tax, for every store, exclusively. Tobacco is roughly 10% of revenue.

The filing lists the failure modes plainly: power outages, severe weather. If the stamping machines break, they outsource and pay more.

That is the shape of the whole risk section. Concentration everywhere.

Their largest fuel supplier is 31% of operating expenses and cost of goods sold. It was 31% last year too, and 31% the year before. They are locked into supply agreements running one to nine years with minimum volume requirements, and if they fail to hit those volumes they owe an underlifting fee to make the supplier whole.

Volumes fell 2% last quarter.

The stores sit in the Northeast, Florida, Germany and Benelux. Four weather systems, four regulatory regimes.

Then the part they frame as good news. Fuel margin hit 51.3 cents per gallon in Q1 2026, up 11.8 cents, because conflict in Iran pushed wholesale prices around and demand for gas is inelastic in the short run.

Market Opportunity

63% of American convenience stores belong to someone who owns fewer than ten of them.

That single number is why a London private equity firm spent a decade buying gas stations on borrowed money.

The market is real. About 150,000 stores. 37% of shoppers walk into one every day, another 42% once or twice a week. Convenience sells more than 80% of the gasoline in this country. Amazon flattened most of retail and barely dented this, because the purchase happens in the moment, not at home waiting on a box.

Against a guy with three stations and a personal guarantee on his fuel contract, you don't need to be brilliant. You need a checkbook.

That checkbook bought them #5 in the US across 24 states and #4 in Europe.

Now read the growth plan. Rebrand 600 to 700 stores over five years at $250K to $520K each. They've done 77. Put fried chicken fryers in 500 stores by 2030, up from 31 today.

Meanwhile same-store gallons fell 1.2% last year. Inside sales fell 1.7%.

The fragmentation was the opportunity when they were buying. It isn't the opportunity now that they're selling.

Product

Gas is not the loss leader. It is the largest source of gross profit in this company.

I had assumed the opposite. Price fuel near cost, get them through the door, sell a Snickers at 40 points. It's the other way around. Fuel earns about a dime on the dollar, but they moved 2.76 billion gallons of it last year at 43.8 cents of margin, and those dimes outrun everything inside the store combined.

Which means you cannot model this off the $16.3 billion of revenue. Most of that is wholesale gasoline passing through the register on its way back to Irving Oil. Start at $2.7 billion of gross profit and work down.

Then it splits into three companies. COCO is owned and operated, highest margin, highest risk. CONCO is owned by them and run by a dealer who cuts a rent check and handles the guy returning a Fanta. Other is a third party they just supply fuel to.

The US is 96% COCO. Europe is 40%.

So one ticker, two continents, three operating models, and a scale advantage that runs on machine-learning fuel pricing across 3,242 sites.

In 2025 that pricing model lost them US market share. They reset it mid-year and gave margin back to win customers.

Business Model

Gas is not the loss leader in this company. It is the single largest source of gross profit.

I assumed the opposite going in. Price fuel near cost, get them through the door, make the money on a Snickers at 40 points. It runs the other way.

Fuel earns about a dime on the dollar. But they sold 2.76 billion gallons of it last year at 43.8 cents of margin, and those dimes add up to more gross profit than everything inside the store combined.

So you cannot read this off the $16.3 billion of revenue. Most of that is wholesale gasoline passing through the register on its way back to the refiner. Start at $2.7 billion of gross profit and work down.

Then it splits into three businesses. COCO: they own it and run it, highest margin, highest risk. CONCO: they own the dirt, a dealer runs the store and cuts a rent check. Other: someone else owns everything, they just supply the fuel.

The US is 96% COCO. Europe is 40%.

One ticker. Two continents. Three operating models.

The edge is scale, run through a machine-learning pricing model across 3,242 sites. In 2025 that model lost them US market share, and they reset it mid-year.

Management Team: 

Russell Colaco - Chief Executive Officer

Colaco ran finance before he ran the company. He was Group CFO from June 2024, took the CEO chair in April 2025, and joined the board in June 2026. Before Cumberland Farms he was CFO of Foster Farms, a $3 billion food company, with two years at Campbell Soup, four as CFO of JBS Foods International, and nine at Morgan Stanley advising consumer and retail clients on M&A. Booth MBA. The résumé is deal-making and food. Which fits, because this company is a decade of deals wearing a food name.

Mark Segal - Chief Financial Officer

Segal has done this before. He was CFO of Spin Master for roughly two decades across two stints and led its IPO in 2015. COO of Canada Goose. CFO of Husky Injection Molding. He started in July 2025 and inherited 8x leverage and $668 million of interest against $208 million of operating income.

Erik Chalut - Chief Legal Officer

Chalut joined Weber, the grill company, as deputy GC during its 2021 IPO, then became GC. Before that, Kellogg, where he worked on selling Keebler. He arrived June 2025.

Investment

Strip the nostalgia and this deal comes down to one number: 21x.

That's what you pay in enterprise value for $693 million of Adjusted EBITDA. $9 billion of equity, plus $5.8 billion of net debt, for a gross profit line that hasn't grown since 2023.

Casey's is the comp the bankers want you to use. It trades at 24x, but it grew EBITDA 24% last year and runs prepared food like a real QSR. Cumberland grew nothing.

The honest comp is ARKO. A rollup of regional brands nobody's heard of, levered at 8x, converting company stores to dealer stores, franchising fried chicken, leaning on a loyalty program, and it just took a subsidiary public to pay down debt. Sound familiar? ARKO trades at 11.5x and the whole company is worth under a billion.

So they're asking roughly $6.8 billion more than the market pays for the company Cumberland actually resembles.

The bet is deleveraging. IPO plus the Australia sale takes leverage to about 5.5x. But even then, $4 billion of remaining debt still costs north of $400 million a year against $208 million of operating income.

The whole thing only pencils if fried chicken and new signage reignite growth.

Competition

Cumberland Farms names its competition, but the tell is who isn't in the comp set at all.

Start with the fight for the customer. Existing convenience retailers, forecourt operators, grocery, supermarkets, fast food, plus non-traditional players like Costco and club stores that entered retail fuel and promote hard on price to pull people inside. The company's edge here is scale: machine-learning fuel pricing across 3,242 sites, procurement contracts a four-station operator in Worcester can never match. In 2025 that pricing model lost them US share and they had to reset it mid-year.

Then the longer war. EV charging companies and car manufacturers moving into loyalty and energy. In the EU, EVs were 26% of new car sales in 2024 and 4% of cars actually on the road. The fleet turns over slowly, which is exactly why they're selling you the American business first, where that shift is further out.

But here's the comp set that gates the multiple. Wawa, Sheetz, QuikTrip, Buc-ee's, RaceTrac are all private, family or employee owned. Every convenience operator anyone actually admires stayed off the public market.

The four you're left to compare against are Casey's, Circle K, Murphy USA, and ARKO.

The best in this business chose not to sell. That's the competition.

Financials

Cumberland Farms shows $16.3 billion of revenue. That is the least useful number in the filing.

Start with what to ignore. Revenue fell 4%, down three straight years, and almost all of it is the wholesale cost of gasoline passing through the register on its way back to the refiner. Model off the $16 billion and you'll land somewhere insane.

Start at gross profit instead. $2.7 billion, and it hasn't grown since 2023. That's the real top line. Adjusted EBITDA of $693 million, down 5%. A net loss of $145 million from continuing operations.

Then the number that reframes everything. Interest expense was $668 million in 2025, against $208 million of operating income. Interest ran 322% of operating income. The stores made a dollar and the lenders took three.

The $1.9 billion of net income in 2023 wasn't a business. It was a sale-leaseback, 414 properties sold for $1.5 billion and a $920 million gain, cash straight to lenders.

One line to watch is FX. Euro debt remeasured into dollars swung a $152 million gain in FY2025 and a $51 million loss in Q1 2026. Non-operational noise that'll make year one of public earnings look erratic.

Closing thoughts

Cumberland Farms files one of the stranger stories to reach the public market this decade. A single petrol station in Bury, England, bought in 2001 and built on borrowed money into a 3,242-store empire across two continents, half of it sold back off to survive, now going public under the name of a Massachusetts dairy chain it adopted 19 days before filing.

The green shoots are real. Q1 2026 Adjusted EBITDA up 34%. Fuel margin up 11.8 cents. Loyalty from 300,000 to 6 million members in thirteen months. Fried chicken that returns $175K on a $150K fryer.

But here's the verdict. This offering asks $14.8 billion of enterprise value, 21x, for a company geared at 8x whose interest ate 322% of operating income last year. ARKO, the honest comp, trades at 11.5x and is worth under a billion.

The fried chicken is worth owning. The balance sheet is not. At $9 billion, you're paying upfront for growth a fryer can't deliver.

Sudhir Syal is the President at Orios Venture Partners. Sudhir spent fifteen years on both sides of the table. He covered India's earliest startups as a journalist, then went and grew three of them himself across Indonesia, UAE, SGP, and India.

If you enjoyed our analysis, we’d very much appreciate you sharing with a friend.

Tweets of the week

Here are the options I have for us to work together. If any of them are interesting to you - hit me up!

What do you think about my bi-weekly Newsletter? Love it | Okay-ish | Stop it

Reply

Avatar

or to participate